Own a Big Sky or Whitefish Rental From New Jersey or New York? How Montana Taxes the Rent
Net rent from Montana real estate is Montana source income, so a New Jersey or New York owner who must file a federal return files a Montana Form 2 as a nonresident, with Schedule II. Montana does not tax the rent by itself. It figures tax on your whole income as if you lived there, then multiplies by the share of your income that came from Montana.

The statute behind the ratio. Montana law imposes on a nonresident a tax "equal to the tax computed under 15-30-2103 as if the nonresident individual, estate, or trust were a resident during the entire tax year, multiplied by the ratio of Montana source income to total income from all sources" (15-30-2104, MCA). The definition of Montana source income lists "net rents from real property and tangible personal property located in the state" (15-30-2101, MCA).
| Step | Line or schedule | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Form 2, page 1 | Starts from federal taxable income, not federal AGI, since Montana's 2024 simplification |
| 2 | Form 2, page 2 | Tax on all of it at resident rates, ordinary income and long-term gains separately |
| 3 | Schedule II, ordinary ratio | Montana source ordinary income, such as net rent from the Big Sky condo, over total ordinary income |
| 4 | Schedule II, capital gains ratio | Montana source net long-term gains over all net long-term gains |
| 5 | Schedule II result | Each ratio times its resident-basis tax; the two results add to your Montana tax |
Why a loss year still means a return. If you "incurred or reported capital or passive losses, you must file a Montana tax return to track the sourcing of the losses." And the 30-day exclusion for short work trips does not help a nonresident who "also has a rental property located in Montana."
Depreciation follows the federal return. Montana defines the Internal Revenue Code as the Code "as amended," and its booklet says "Depreciation, depletion, and amortization deductions must be the same for federal and Montana income tax purposes." So the federal "100-percent additional first year depreciation deduction for qualified property acquired after January 19, 2025" (IRS) lowers Montana source rent in the same year, subject to the federal passive loss rules in IRS Publication 925. Our real estate tax and accounting page covers cost segregation.
Montana Income Tax Rates for 2026 and 2027: 5.65%, Then 5.4%
House Bill 337 cut the top rate from 5.9% for 2025 to 5.65% for 2026 and 5.4% for 2027, and widened the 4.7% bracket for a single filer from $21,100 to $47,500, then to $65,000. A single filer pays 4.7% on the first $47,500 of Montana taxable income for 2026 and 5.65% above it; for 2027 the 4.7% band runs to $65,000. Net long-term capital gains keep separate rates of 3.0% and 4.1%.
Where the 4.7% band ends, 2026 and 2027
Montana taxable income taxed at 4.7%, by filing status, in thousands of dollars; income above it is taxed at 5.65% for 2026 and 5.4% for 2027.
- 2026
- 2027
Show the data
| Filing status | 2026 | 2027 |
|---|---|---|
| Single | $48 | $65 |
| Married filing jointly | $95 | $130 |
| Head of household | $71 | $98 |
| Filing status | 2026: 4.7% on income up to | 2026 rate above | 2027: 4.7% on income up to | 2027 rate above |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Single or married filing separately | $47,500 | 5.65% | $65,000 | 5.4% |
| Married filing jointly or surviving spouse | $95,000 | 5.65% | $130,000 | 5.4% |
| Head of household | $71,250 | 5.65% | $97,500 | 5.4% |
| Net long-term capital gains | 3.0% within the band left after ordinary income | 4.1% | 3.0% within the band left after ordinary income | 4.1% |
How the gains rate works. The 3.0% applies only to gains that fit inside the 4.7% band after your ordinary income fills it. The statute says that "if the total nonqualified taxable income is $95,000 or greater, all of the net long-term capital gains are taxed at 4.1%" for a joint return in 2026. For clients whose wages alone pass that line, a Montana-source long-term gain is taxed at 4.1% before the Schedule II ratio applies.
What 2027 does not yet show. The 2027 statute tells the Department to adjust brackets "By November 1 of each year" for inflation. The 2027 figures above are the ones in the law and the Department's 2027 table; we do not estimate an adjusted amount.
Montana's 2026 Property Tax on Second Homes: 1.90% Flat Versus the Long-Term Rental Rate
Starting with tax year 2026, Montana sorts every house into one of two groups. A primary residence or a long-term rental gets tiered rates of 0.76%, 0.90%, 1.10% and 1.90% on slices of market value. A second home, a short-term rental or a vacant lot pays a flat 1.90% on all of its value. Those rates produce taxable value, and the local mill levy then sets the bill.
1.9%Flat rate on the full market value of a second home or short-term rental for 2026; the local mill levy then sets the bill.
| Use of the house in 2026 | Rate on market value | Who qualifies |
|---|---|---|
| Primary residence (homestead) | 0.76% on the first $378,000; 0.90% to $756,000; 1.10% to $1,511,999; 1.90% above $1,512,000 | Owner lives there 7+ months, current on taxes, owned by individuals or a grantor revocable trust |
| Long-term rental | Same tiers | Rented 28+ days at a time, 7+ months of the year, as the tenant's residence; an LLC may own it |
| Second home, short-term rental, vacant residential lot | Flat 1.90% | Everything that does not enroll |
| House on qualified agricultural land, used as a second home or short-term rental | 1.35% flat on the residence; land 2.05% | Parcels of 160+ acres qualify automatically |

The formula. "Market Value × Tax Rate = Taxable Value," then "Taxable Value × Mill Levy = Property Tax." Above $1,512,000 the top slice pays 1.90% either way, so the change bites hardest below that line.
Enrolling a long-term rental for 2027. The rate is not automatic for a rental. The application window for 2027 is "May 4, 2026 - March 1, 2027," and the rental FAQ says an application without the prior year's monthly rent, income and expenses will be denied. An owner who later converts the unit to nightly rentals must tell the Department within 30 days, and the house moves to the standard rate the next year.
Leasing to family. If the Department disregards a lease of a weekend house to your spouse, it reclassifies the property and back taxes are owed, and a false application carries "a penalty equal to three times the additional taxes plus interest" (DOR, Long-term Rental FAQs). We do not recommend that arrangement. County bills are due in halves by November 30 and May 31 (15-16-102, MCA).
No Sales Tax, but 8% Lodging Tax and a Resort Tax on Nightly Rentals
Montana "does not have a general-use sales tax," yet a vacation rental is a lodging facility. Each stay of fewer than 30 continuous days carries a 4% lodging facility use tax and a 4% lodging facility sales tax, 8% combined, on what the guest pays for the accommodation. Inside a designated resort area, a local resort tax is added: 4% in Big Sky and 3% in Whitefish.
30 daysContinuous days of rental to the same guest at which the 8% state lodging tax stops applying.
Who files when Airbnb or Vrbo takes the payment. Senate Bill 52 "requires short-term rental marketplaces to register and collect, report, and pay taxes on any sale facilitated by the short-term rental marketplace." The owner is not finished, though: lodging taxpayers "will still be required to pay taxes on any sales that occur outside of a short-term rental marketplace," and each lodging business must get a seller's permit before it rents. Returns are quarterly, due the last day of the month after the quarter (DOR, Lodging Facility Sales and Use Tax).
Tax on a nightly stay, by location
State lodging tax next to the local resort tax, as percentages of the charge for the stay.
- State lodging tax
- Local resort tax
Show the data
| Location | State lodging tax | Local resort tax |
|---|---|---|
| Big Sky | 8% | 4% |
| Whitefish | 8% | 3% |
| Bozeman | 8% | 0% |
| Location | State lodging tax | Local resort tax | Local filing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Big Sky | 8% | 4% on lodging stays of 30 days or less, per the district | Monthly, by the end of the following month, through MUNIRevs; a return is required even when nothing was collected |
| Whitefish | 8% | 3% on lodging, retail, bars and restaurants | Transmittal and payment by the 20th day of the following month |
| West Yellowstone, Red Lodge, Gardiner and other listed resort areas | 8% | 3% on the Department's list | Set by each resort area |
| Bozeman, Missoula and other towns not on the list | 8% | None on the Department's list | No resort tax return |
The Big Sky rate conflict. The Department's resort tax table still lists Big Sky at 3%, and it says "The maximum resort tax rate is 3%." The Big Sky Resort Area District, which collects the tax, says "The rate of the resort tax is 4% of the retail value of the items or services sold." We follow the district, which collects it, and confirm with each platform whether it remits the resort tax for your listing.
Holding Montana Property in an LLC: Pass-Through Entity Tax, Withholding and Composite Returns
A partnership or S corporation with Montana income has three ways to pay for a nonresident owner: withholding at the top individual rate, a composite return, or the elective pass-through entity tax (PTET). The PTET equals "the highest marginal tax rate in effect under 15-30-2103" times the owners' Montana source income, which by that cross-reference is 5.65% for 2026. The election is annual and irrevocable for the year.
$1,000Montana source share at which an entity withholds for a nonresident owner, unless a PTET election, composite return or Form PT-AGR applies.
The rate on the Department's page. The Department's PTET page still says the tax "is a 5.9% of an affected owner’s distributive share of Montana source income," the rate that applied before House Bill 337. The statute ties the entity rate to the top individual rate for "the tax year the election is made" (15-30-3326, MCA), so we compute 2026 at 5.65% and 2027 at 5.4%, and we will confirm against the 2026 Form PTE instructions when they post.
| Option | What the entity does | Owner's Montana return |
|---|---|---|
| Withholding (default) | Remits "the highest marginal tax rate" on a nonresident's Montana source share once it reaches $1,000 | Owner files Form 2 and claims the withholding |
| Form PT-AGR | Owner agrees to file and pay; no withholding | Owner files Form 2; the agreement is "automatically rejected if received after the due date" |
| Composite return | Entity pays for eligible nonresident owners with no other Montana income | "does not need to file a Montana income tax return" |
| PTET election | Entity pays at the top rate, made on a timely Form PTE including extensions | None, when all of the owner's Montana income bore the entity tax |
Timing. Form PTE is due March 15, extended to September 15 (DOR, Pass-Through Entities), and the election "is irrevocable for the year it is made."
The property tax side of an LLC. An LLC can keep the long-term rental rate, but a house "owned by a limited liability company" cannot get the homestead rate, which matters if you plan to live in the Bozeman house later.
How the New Jersey and New York Resident Credits Treat Montana Tax
New Jersey and New York both credit Montana income tax on income they also tax, capped at what they would charge on it. Lodging, resort and property taxes are not income taxes and earn no credit. The entity-level tax is where the two states part: New York's list of substantially similar entity taxes names Montana's PTET starting with 2023, and New Jersey's published list does not name Montana.
| Question | New Jersey (Schedule NJ-COJ) | New York (Form IT-112-R) |
|---|---|---|
| What qualifies | Income or wage tax paid on "the same income in the same year" | Income "sourced to and taxed by another state" while you were a resident |
| The cap | "Your credit cannot be more than the amount you would have paid if you earned the income in New Jersey" | The credit "may not decrease" New York tax below what you would owe with that income excluded |
| A Montana rental loss | GIT-3B: a loss in one category "cannot be used to offset gains in another category" | Only income sourced to and taxed by Montana enters the computation |
| Montana PTET paid by an LLC | Not on the Division's list of substantially similar taxes, "current as of October 2, 2023" | Listed: Mont. Code Ann. § 15-30-3326, starting with 2023 |
What the New Jersey gap means for an LLC. The Division credits another state's entity tax that is "substantially similar" to BAIT and lists the states it accepts; that list is dated October 2, 2023. Until the Division adds Montana or publishes a ruling, we model an electing Montana LLC owned by a Bergen County family as if the New Jersey credit for the entity tax is uncertain, and compare it with plain withholding or a PT-AGR.
For a New York City resident. IT-112-R offsets New York State tax only. Our New York 2026 and 2027 tax guide covers the state and city side, and our New Jersey 2026 and 2027 tax guide covers BAIT and the rest of the New Jersey return.
Moving to Montana From New Jersey or New York: Residency, a Remote New York Job and Equity Pay
Montana treats you as a resident if you are "domiciled or maintain a permanent place of abode in Montana," and taxes a resident's income from everywhere. In the year you arrive, you file as a part-year resident on Schedule II, and Montana taxes what you receive after the move plus any Montana-source income before it. The risk most movers miss is a New York job kept after the move.

What the Department looks at. Its list runs from a Montana driver's license and voter registration to where you get mail and see your doctor, and "a person does not need to meet all of the factors listed to be considered a resident" (DOR, Montana Residency). New York, for its part, defines domicile as the home "you intend to return to or remain in after being away" (NY, Nonresident FAQs), and New Jersey's GIT-6 makes you a part-year resident in the year you leave.
Keeping a New York job from Montana. New York says a nonresident whose primary office is in the state is taxed on telecommuting days "unless your employer has established a bona fide employer office at your telecommuting location." Montana's credit page answers the other half: an employee who "worked remotely in Montana and is subject to income tax in another state based on the “convenience of the employer” rule" gets no Montana credit, "because the income was derived in Montana" (DOR, Credit for Income Tax Paid to Another State). The same wages can be taxed by both states with no relief on either return.
| Income | Montana, after you become a resident | New York, as a nonresident |
|---|---|---|
| Wages for days worked from your Montana home for a New York office | Montana source: compensation "while a resident of the state" | Taxable unless the employer set up a bona fide office at your location |
| Options, restricted stock and SARs granted while you worked in New York | Taxable as compensation received while a Montana resident | Allocated by the "New York workday fraction" over a period that "may include periods in which you were a New York State resident" |
| Gain on stock you sell after the move | Montana source: gain on intangible property "received or accrued while a resident of the state" | Not addressed on the New York pages we read |
| Net rent from the New Jersey house you keep | Montana taxes it; a credit for New Jersey tax may apply | Not applicable |
Equity that vests after the move. New York's IT-203 instructions list "stock options, and stock appreciation rights" among New York services income. Montana credits tax only on income "derived from sources within the other state," up to Montana's own tax on it. We found no Department page setting Montana's allocation period for equity, so we map grant, vest and exercise dates against your workdays in each state before the first Montana return. Our tax preparation and planning page shows how that plan runs through the year.
Buying or Selling Montana Real Estate: No Transfer Tax, a Realty Transfer Certificate and the Gain
Montana's constitution rules out a deed tax. Article VIII, Section 17 says the state or any local government "may not impose any tax, including a sales tax, on the sale or transfer of real property." What the county does require is a Realty Transfer Certificate, filed with the deed.
The Realty Transfer Certificate. A Form RTC "must be filed with the County Clerk and Recorder at the same time the deed is filed for recordation," and the grantor and grantee names must match the deed. A sale price is not required for some transfers, including a "Merger, consolidation, or reorganization of a business entity" or a gift (DOR, Realty Transfer Certificates; Montana Constitution, Art. VIII, Sec. 17).
Selling. A nonresident's gain on Montana real estate is Montana source income as gain "attributable to the sale or other transfer of tangible property located in the state." A long-term gain goes through Schedule II's capital gains ratio at the 3.0% and 4.1% rates. If the house sits in a single-member LLC, the booklet says the sale "is considered a sale of the assets of the company," so the result is the same as selling the house. We did not find a Montana rule requiring withholding on a nonresident individual's sale in the Department pages we read; we confirm with the closing agent on every file. On the home-state return, the gain is income taxed by both states and goes into the same credit computation as the rent.
Before you buy in Big Sky, the Flathead Valley or ranch country. We model the purchase before you sign: year-one federal, Montana and home-state tax, the 1.90% property rate against the long-term rental rate, lodging and resort tax, and personal or LLC ownership. It starts with a $2,000 purchase modeling engagement, credited toward year one when you sign.
Montana Tax Dates for the 2026 and 2027 Tax Years
These are the Montana dates a New Jersey or New York owner or mover plans around, each from the office that sets it. The state lodging return comes quarterly and Big Sky's resort return monthly. The 2026 Form 2 booklet is not out, so return dates follow the Department's posted due dates.
- Every Montana property owner
First half of 2026 county property tax (or 30 days after the notice is postmarked, if later)
Source: 15-16-102, MCA
- Individuals; PTET and pass-through withholding follow the top rate
5.4% top rate and the wider 4.7% bracket begin
Source: 15-30-2103, MCA
- Owners with direct bookings outside a platform
Lodging facility sales and use tax return for October to December 2026
- Owners who live in the house 7+ months, or rent it long term
Last day to enroll a homestead or long-term rental for the 2027 reduced rate
- Partnerships and S corporations with Montana income
2026 Form PTE, and the PTET election on a timely return (extended returns: September 15, 2027)
Source: DOR, Pass-Through Entities
- Nonresidents with Montana source income, and part-year residents
2026 Form 2 with Schedule II, and payment
Source: DOR, Individual Income Tax
Source: each row's linked page; the resort rows rest on the Big Sky Resort Area District FAQ and City of Whitefish, Resort Tax.
The Department's six-month extension covers filing the Form 2, "but this extension does not apply to payments."
Montana Tax Law for 2026 and 2027: Enacted, Proposed or Not Yet Published
The 2027 rules were set in the 2025 session: House Bill 337 for income tax, and HB 231 and SB 542 for property tax. What has not caught up is the paperwork, including the Department's PTET page, its resort tax table and the 2026 booklets.
| Status | Item | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Enacted | Top rate 5.65% for 2026 and 5.4% from January 1, 2027; 4.7% band to $47,500 single for 2026 and $65,000 for 2027 (House Bill 337; Ch. 227, L. 2025) | 15-30-2103, MCA |
| Enacted | Homestead and long-term rental tiers; flat 1.90% on second homes and short-term rentals from 2026 (HB 231, SB 542) | DOR, Understanding Montana Property Taxes |
| Enacted | PTET at the highest individual rate, elected each year (Ch. 702, L. 2023) | 15-30-3326, MCA |
| Enacted | Constitutional ban on real property transfer taxes (CI-105, 2010) | Montana Constitution, Art. VIII, Sec. 17 |
| Proposed | None found on the pages we read; the Secretary of State's ballot page could not be read, so we recheck after November 3, 2026 | Not applicable |
| Not yet published | 2027 brackets after the November 1 inflation adjustment; 2027 property tax bands; 2026 Form 2 and Form PTE instructions | 15-30-2103, MCA; DOR, 2026 Tax Information |
| Not yet published | A PTET page at the 2026 rate (the page read still shows 5.9%), and New Jersey's position on Montana's PTET | DOR, Pass-Through Entity Tax; NJ BAIT FAQ |
We do not estimate any figure the agencies have not published. When the Department posts the adjusted 2027 brackets or new property tax bands, we will update this guide and have it reviewed again.
Before You Buy, Rent Out or Move to Montana, Talk to a Partner
A Montana house owned from New Jersey or New York touches five filings: the federal return, the Form 2 with Schedule II, the lodging and resort returns, the county property tax bill and the home-state credit. A move adds a sixth, the last NJ-1040 or New York return. The calls worth making come before closing, before March 1 enrollment and before an LLC elects PTET. Other states we cover sit in our state tax guides.


Who you would be working with. TC Advisors CPA is a two-partner practice in Hackensack that Nick Termine, CPA and Stephen Calvo, CPA opened in 2025. Nick started in KPMG's tax group advising wealthy families and closely held businesses; Stephen built his career inside two Big Four firms. Our licenses are New Jersey (20CC04335100) and New York (133101) only, and we hold no Montana license. Our Montana work is the out-of-state part of a New Jersey or New York client's taxes, done by the same two partners from 185 Linden St #201, Hackensack, NJ 07601. Read more about the partners.
How it starts. Business owners engage us on a 12-month monthly retainer, with the fee set after a first conversation. Investors begin with a $2,000 purchase modeling engagement, credited toward year one when you sign. Phone (201) 343-1621, weekdays from 9:30 AM to 4:30 PM.
Construction
Real estate
Medical practices
Professional firms